The Silver Sgian Dubh is awarded annual at the Winter SCOT Meeting. It is awarded to the Scottish Trainer of the Year. They are nominated by trainees throughout Scotland and there are regional “runners-up”.
2024 (Presented January 2025)
Mr Tim Dougall (North)
As the Summer SCOT Meeting could not proceed F2F due to adverse weather, the presentation was made by the North Region Trainees at a separate event
Citation
Trainer 1 exemplifies excellence in orthopaedic surgeon training by consistently going above and beyond the call of duty. His dedication to fostering a supportive and dynamic learning environment is evident through his innovative teaching methods and unwavering commitment to his trainees’ success. Trainer 1 ensures that each trainee receives personalised instruction in theatre, tailoring his approach to meet their unique learning needs and styles. This individualised attention not only enhances the trainees’ technical skills but also boosts their confidence and professional growth.
Furthermore, Trainer 1‘s commitment extends beyond the classroom and operating room. He mentors his trainees, offering guidance and support for their career development. His open-door policy encourages trainees to seek advice and discuss challenges, fostering a culture of continuous learning and improvement. Trainer 1 frequently spends hours of his own time running through mock vivas for senior trainees in preparation for their FRCS part 2 examination. He always encourages the trainee to perform to the best of their ability and inspires confidence. Trainer 1’s dedication to his trainees’ success exemplify what it means to go above and beyond in orthopaedic surgeon training.
Regional Winners
- West: Mr Brian Syme
- South-East: Mr Mo El-Sayad
- East: Mr Alasdair MacInnes
2023
Mr Mike Reidy (North)(Also Awarded BOTA UK Trainer of the Year)
Other Regional Trainers of the Year
- Mr Himanshu Shekar (East)
- Mr Calum Cree (West)
- Miss Ellie Davidson (South-East)
2022
Mr Gerrard Cousins (North)
Other Regional Trainers of the Year
- Mr Colin Drury (West)
- Mr Stephen Dalgleish (East)
- Miss Eleanor Davidson (South-East)
2022
…
2021
Not awarded due to COVID
2020
Mr Doug Robinson (East)
2019
Mr Fraser Harrold (East)
2018
Mr Andy Ballantyne (South-East)
2017
Mr Tim Dougall (North)
Other Regional Trainers of the Year
- Mr Robert Cook (South East)
- Mr Neil Valentine (East)
- Mr Michael Foxworthy (West)
